PHROC stands in solidarity with the Manasrah family for refusing to receive their son’s frozen body


The Palestinian Human Rights Organisations Council (PHROC) said in a press release on Tuesday that it supports the decision taken by the family of 15-year-old Hassan Khaled Manasrah, from occupied Jerusalem, to not receive his body which was in a humiliating and degrading state.

Hassan was killed by the Israeli Occupying Forces (IOF) on 12 October 2015 while with his cousin, Ahmad Manasrah,14, in the illegal “Pisgat Ze’ev” settlement in Beit Hanina, North Jerusalem.

Since then, Israel withheld Hassan’s body and detained Ahmad.

Deplorable footage has been released showing Ahmad in hospital and another of him subject to harsh interrogation.

The Israeli authorities placed various conditions on the families of Hassan Manasrah and 21-year-old Omar Yasser Iskafi, also from Jerusalem, in order to release their bodies.

The terms were as follows: the bodies would be released on 22 March 2016 as long as each family deposits 20,000 shekels to guarantee that no more than 30 people participate in each funeral and that they be buried immediately.

That day at approximately 1:00 am, the Israeli authorities deployed its forces and set up barriers around Bab Al-Asbat (Lion’s Gate) in order to deliver the bodies.

Hassan’s family were shocked to see their son completely frozen. They could not identify him, hold him, or have a proper final goodbye.

“We accepted the preconditions set by the [Israeli] occupation so we can bury him [Manasra] in dignity, and our only demand was that the body shouldn’t be frozen. The [Israeli] occupation is trying through these humiliating practices to put pressure on families. This child had been executed under ambiguous conditions which nobody knows, as they have never been revealed,” Manasra’s uncle Ahmad said to the local press.

Lawyer for Palestinian prisoners’ rights group Addameer Muhammad Mahmoud confirmed that the teen’s father refused to receive the body of his son because it was frozen.

“It was a personal decision by the family,” he said, adding that the Israeli authorities had previously agreed to allot enough time after the removal of bodies from the Abu Kabir Forensic Institute in order that they not be frozen on delivery.

Meanwhile the Iskafi family buried Omar that night. 

14 Palestinian bodies remain in Israeli custody, including three children and one woman. All of them were individuals were from Jerusalem.

The longest, Tha’er Abu Ghazaleh, has been held since 8 October 2015. Countless bodies remain in the ‘cemeteries of numbers’;, while some have been there for decades, another 19 bodies were placed there following the 2014 attacks on the Gaza Strip.

The practice of withholding the bodies of the deceased amounts to collective punishment against Palestinians.

It also obstructs autopsies from being carried out, potentially concealing evidence of extrajudicial killing.

On their press release, PHROC calls on:

1. Israeli authorities to: 

a. Release all Palestinian bodies held, without prior conditions, so that their families can bury them in dignity. The practice of withholding bodies is illegal. Therefore, the release of the bodies should not be negotiated and rather delivered without imposed conditions or terms.

b. Carry out prompt, impartial, independent, effective, and transparent investigations  into the killing of Palestinians and ensure accountability for all perpetrators involved.

2. Palestinian officials to organise a local committee of physicians, including international experts, to observe the autopsy process of all bodies and investigate the real reasons behind the death.

3. The International Red Cross to issue a statement prohibiting the practice of withholding bodies as it contravenes international humanitarian law.